I’ve had the pleasure (or misfortune?) over the last several months of again working with Ontario’s No-Fault and Accident Benefits system. Accident benefits was not a stranger to me, as I had begun my career working under OMPP, the original No-Fault legislation, and moving on to the much maligned Bill 164. The last time I had worked with Ontario Accident Benefits was in the late 1990’s, under what was then called Bill 59, brought in by the Harris Conservatives – I then moved to western Canada for a dozen or so years.
My memory of Accident Benefits is pretty good – unfortunately the legislation has changed several times since I was here. The strongest memory that I had were the strict timelines that we had to deal with under Bill 164, and that continues through today – ostensibly to the benefit of the insured or claimant, but in reality I’m no longer certain who this serves. The more I have learned about our current system, the more disappointed I am that we have come to this point, and the more I believe that no amount of government tinkering will fix the Ontario Accident Benefits system.
There is a belief that the system is rife with fraud – I’ve seen it and I have to agree. However, I think it is somewhat disingenuous to say that it is the entire system, everywhere. My very limited anecdotal research tells me that it is a problem centred mostly in the GTA – other centres have their problems, but nothing like the issues in Toronto itself; natural, given the size of the population.
I’ve seen claimants in Windsor receiving dubious treatment in Toronto. Imagine travelling three to four hours, three times a week, for treatment that is certainly available in your own city. I’ve seen clinics invoicing for treatment that the claimant did not take. I’ve seen clinics intentionally attempt to overwhelm adjusters with paperwork to hope that they miss a deadline, so that they can immediately bill for specious treatment. I’ve seen billings for environmental assessments for “driving rehabilitation”. I’ve seen claims submitted for people who have fist-fights in a stationary vehicle, and claim that the injuries are as a result of the use of the vehicle. Frankly, everyone gets their house cleaned for them, and submits expenses a family member cleaning their home. It is, frankly, a sad state.
I was in Alberta through the hand-wringing as the $4,000 minor injury cap and the Minor Injury Regulation went into place. I worked through the court challenges, and watched the plaintiff’s bar as they stalled and delayed on each and every claim while they waited for the challenges to be heard. The astounding thing is this: the costs of those claims before the cap was less than what we are paying out on similar injuries right now in Ontario. The system here is broken.
It isn’t just the claims payouts – I believe that the benefits of a no-fault accident benefits system far outweigh the often-acrimonious tort systems’ detractions. The biggest problem I see is that the AB system has gone from one where the adjuster helps the insured/claimant recover, to one where the adjuster is an automaton. Certainly deadlines are necessary, but their abuse from all parties in the system leads to an inability of an Accident Benefits adjuster to really be anything other than a claims and paper processor. They follow procedure. There are knee-jerk rejections of treatments due to the nature of the treatment, the clinic it came from, or the law firm that represents the client. The adjusters also incur as much cost in expense as they incur in treatment for the benefit of an insured/claimant, as without doing so, the treatment costs would spiral out of control.
The changes proposed by the Ontario Government will be moderately helpful at best. The Minor Injury Regulation and the reduced medical expense limit of $50,000 won’t stop the clinics from trying to charge $10,000-$15,000 per claimant. The reformed timelines will certainly help relieve some pressure on our adjusters, but new ways will be found to ensure that the vendors are able to push through ridiculous costs and expenses for dubious treatment. Six months from now, many of the same problems will still be there – just with a different response timeline. What the industry needs to reduce costs is not reduced limits, but more power for an adjuster to say something that is currently not allowed in the system: NO. There seems to be legislated inability for our adjusters to do so. If you have something that isn’t covered by your homeowner’s insurance, your adjusters are free to say no. But under this system the closest we can say is “I don’t think that’s right, so I will spend $2,000 for someone to tell me that we should say no. Then you will dispute it, and I will dispute your dispute. Then we will go to a mediator and argue about it.” Mediation is a totally different topic all together – and one to be addressed later.
We need to have MPPs come and watch what happens in a claims department for a few days. Let them come and see how hard it is to have non-cynical, non-jaded staff. Let them see how bureaucratic and broken the system has become. I don’t believe that anyone in Queens Park has any idea how frustrated our people are. The conventional thought right now is that most Accident Benefits adjusters will last 8 years before they burn out. 8 years is a short career in the insurance industry. Let them see how little power the adjuster has, how paper-heavy it is, how the whole system groans under the sheer weight of endless reports and rebuttals; at that point, maybe we will get the change in the system that will restore some balance and provide the adjuster some power – and I don’t think you can do that by changing the current framework. You have to give back the power to say no. It just might save some of our great people. What a radical concept.

3 thoughts on “Ontario Auto – don’t fix it, replace it.”