The Current Sad State of Affairs
The Current Sad State of Affairs
Here is the thing I find most disheartening about this – the insurance industry has created an untenable animal. We should just get another quote, surely someone else can get something done for us, right? Switch brokers.
That isn’t so easy. There are only three major brokers that really specialize in this business in the lower mainland, and they all compete hammer and tongs for the business; as I mentioned above, my firm is one of those three. Those three brokers all have access to essentially the same markets for their policies – most of which are written on a subscription basis. A subscription policy, in a nutshell, is where multiple insurers make up the total insurance coverage. Insurer A takes 35% of the risk, and taking the biggest share, they are considered the “lead underwriter”; they call the shots, control the claim, and give instructions to the adjuster. The next one takes 20%, and the next three each take 15% to total 100%. Five insurance companies on one risk – a good way to spread the exposure. Except in each of the three cases mentioned above, the brokers were unable to find enough insurers to take enough share to make up 100%, leaving us at 68%, or 60%, or 12%.
Okay, so we need to go out and find more insurers, right? That isn’t so easy, as many insurers have now refused to write strata buildings in BC. Some very major insurers have in fact pulled out in the last 5 years, reducing the capacity. That means that there are only a limited number of players willing to take part in these subscriptions, and those players are being really choosy of both their share, and the buildings that they are willing to underwrite.

Fine, we’ll have a second broker work to quote alongside the incumbent. Keep them honest, and make them work for the business, just like choosing a contractor, right? Unfortunately, there’s a problem inherent to the system: insurers getting blocked. See, if an incumbent broker is marketing a property, they can approach any insurer they want. If that insurer is going to quote for them, and agree to take a little piece of that property, that insurer is now blocked, and unable to quote for any other broker. The system works in the good times by ensuring that an insurance company doesn’t undercut themselves when a second broker is trying to win new business, thereby undercutting the incumbent broker. It’s an honor thing.
Why do they do this? Well, insurers want to be the partner of the broker, and a broker losing a client is a very big deal. The broker wants to force the client to very formally sever their relationship, so at renewal time they can’t simply cut ties by getting a new quote from any and all insurers. The insurers respect this, and therefore will only quote for the first broker that approaches them. Brokers basically call “dibs” on the insurers in the marketplace. In the good times, when there is lots of insurer capacity, this system works.
So what, find new insurers? Go back up to where I’m talking about the insurers that have pulled out in the last 5 years. There are very few insurers out there willing to write strata business in BC, with our spate of water claims and our threat of forest fires and earthquakes. In their desperation, the incumbent broker has likely approached most the viable markets they have access to, some of which are shared with other brokers – they’ve called dibs on all of them, they’ve licked all the donuts. A second broker often can’t put something together, even if they wanted to, as the insurers will all be tied up. This situation is untenable, and I say this while working at a brokerage. Something needs to give.
Click below to continue reading –>

One thought on “The BC Strata Insurance Crisis”